A Surprise Visitor on Our Final Day at the Site

Thursday morning, August 5th:

Some volunteers were cleaning the site for photography, while others (including myself) were erecting fences around the excavated areas. I looked up at a random moment and recognized Israel Finkelstein walking toward the gate area where I have excavated for two weeks.

Israel Finkelstein is a professor of Archaeology at Tel Aviv University. For years, he has been a leading face of Biblical Minimalism, which is a perspective that seeks to minimize the Bible as a relevant source of historical information. He has advocated a revised history of the early Iron Age in his published articles, in a best-selling book, and on various television documentaries. Finkelstein’s revisionist conclusions include:

  • The tribes of Israel were not organized under any significant central government in the 10th century B.C. (According to the biblical timeline, this would be when David established his monarchy.)
  • If David and Solomon existed, they were not monarchs of any significant kingdom. According to Finkelstein, they would have been something like hill-country chieftains or glorified bedouins in (according to him) the poor, small fortified village of Jerusalem.
  • The biblical stories of the early Davidic monarchy, its power and its might are largely fictitious, and must have been crafted centuries later by Israelite priests who desired to create a more glorious history for their people.

On what basis does he advocate these points? Much of it boils down to a lack of evidence. Archaeologists had found plenty of material remains (pottery, structures, etc.) from the centuries before and after David’s time, but very little from the early Iron Age in the 11th and 10th centuries B.C. (Saul, David and Solomon would be in the early Iron Age.) This is not a complete synopsis of Finkelstain’s arguments, but I will save that for another post.

lajlkf

Israel Finkelstein (right) with Yossi Garfinkel, the head archaeologist at Khirbet Qeiyafa (blue shirt) at the site on Thursday morning, August 5th, 2009.

It is risky to argue from what has not been found, because it is possible someone will eventually find it. This is why the Khirbet Qeiyafa excavation has become important. The evidence there so far points to an organized, strong, Jerusalem-centered kingdom in the 10th century B.C. – the early Iron Age of David.

  • Khirbet Qeiyafa has produced pottery and olive pits that have  been dated to the early Iron Age – the time of the biblical King David.
  • An inscription discovered in 2008 appears to be in Hebrew, which helps to link the city to the Israelites.
  • Numerous animal bones have been found, but none of them (so far) have been from pigs. This is a key indicator of Israelite sites since pigs were forbidden under Jewish Law.  Sites from Philistine and other Canaanite cultures typically produce bones from pigs and other non-kosher animals.
  • The Iron Age city had 200,000 tons of stone in its fortifications. This amount is way out of proportion to the city’s size and resources, indicating that a strong centralized government was behind its construction.
  • The city is situated to guard a major highway to Jerusalem, which would explain its strong fortifications.

If this season’s excavations continue to point toward a fortified, early Iron Age Israelite city, it will be strong evidence for the Bible accounts and a powerful blow to Biblical Minimalism. Israel Finkelstein’s visit to Khirbet Qeiyafa is no small thing. We will continue to monitor the evidence and the debate.

sgsdg

Yossi Garfinkel and Israel Finkelstein discussing an Iron Age gate at Khirbet Qeiyafa. Yossi is pointing to the area of the drain I helped to excavate earlier in the week. The drain produced material evidence that, so far, places it squarely in the early Iron Age. Further analysis will yield more evidence regarding the age of the drain and the original gate area.

Advertisements

About LukeChandler

Luke holds an M.A. in Ancient and Classical History and has been an adjunct professor at Florida College in Temple Terrace, Florida. Luke and his wife Melanie have five children. He serves as a minister in English and Spanish with the North Terrace Church of Christ and participates annually in archaeological excavations in Israel. Luke also leads tours to Europe and the Bible Lands.
This entry was posted in Biblical Archaeology, General Archaeology, Israel, Misuses of biblical archaeology and tagged , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

4 Responses to A Surprise Visitor on Our Final Day at the Site

  1. afrankangle says:

    Learning just never seems to stop … and questions keep developing; some good, others not so …. but learning moves us forward, well, that is if one can keep up.

  2. Pingback: Prof. Israel Finkelstein visits Khirbet Qeiyafa « Ferrell’s Travel Blog

  3. barnea says:

    Luke,

    It was such a pleasure having you and your father at the dig.

    I enjoyed our conversation and I believe both of your presence added an element of appreciation and enthusiasm to the rest of the staff, and to our visitors.

    I know you personally experienced the joy of discovery, and from the fist hand experience and immersion in the process have acquired a deeper ability to follow and contribute to the scholarly discussions which revolve around geography, olive pits and bones, architecture, and overall context.

  4. Pingback: A Look at Megiddo – a.k.a. Armageddon | Luke Chandler's Blog

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s